top of page

First to file, but not necessarily in the right forum: Section 11(11) and territorial jurisdiction of the high court

Nov 4
4 min read
Exploring the nuances of jurisdiction: Understanding the implications of filing under Section 11(11) and the territorial jurisdiction of the high court.
Exploring the nuances of jurisdiction: Understanding the implications of filing under Section 11(11) and the territorial jurisdiction of the high court.

Vinay Palaparthy v. A.M. Emanuel and Ors., Civil Miscellaneous Petition No. 286 of 2025, High Court of Karnataka, decided on 7 October 2026 (Justice H.T. Narendra Prasad) Introduction

A party seeking the appointment of an arbitrator under Section 11 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 may assume that approaching a High Court first secures the forum. A recent decision of the Karnataka High Court shows why that assumption can be misplaced. The Court held that Section 11(11) decides which application is to be considered when requests are made to different courts, but it does not give territorial jurisdiction to a court that otherwise lacks it.

Background

The petitioner and his uncle constituted a partnership firm, M/s. Building Solutions and Co., by a Partnership Deed dated 6 March 2007. The firm later entered into two Joint Development Agreements dated 17 April 2018 with Provident Housing Limited. The partnership was reconstituted on 18 June 2018, and the petitioner claims that he was inducted as a partner again in 2022, which respondent Nos. 1 to 3 dispute.

After issuing a notice under Section 21 on 19 March 2025, the petitioner approached the High Court under Sections 11(5) and 11(6), seeking a sole arbitrator under Clause 12 of the Partnership Deed and the arbitration clauses of the two Joint Development Agreements. The respondents raised a preliminary objection on maintainability.

The Joint Development Agreements

The respondents argued that the petitioner was not a signatory to the Joint Development Agreements. The Court relied on an interim order dated 13 August 2025 of a Division Bench of the same Court in COMAP No. 164/2025, arising from the petitioner's Section 9 proceedings. That order recorded that, prima facie, the dispute was between persons claiming to be partners of the firm and did not arise from the Joint Development Agreements. On this basis, the Court held that the petitioner could not invoke those arbitration clauses and that the petition was not maintainable to that extent.

The Partnership Deed and the Question of Seat

The Partnership Deed does not specify a seat, venue or place of arbitration. The Court therefore applied the closest and most intimate connection test, relying on paragraph 18 of J&K Economic Reconstruction Agency v. Rash Builders India Pvt. Ltd., 2026 SCC OnLine SC 596, which records that the intention of the parties, discerned from the agreement and surrounding circumstances, is the paramount factor.

The Court noted that the firm's registered office is at Secunderabad, its business is carried on there, and it is registered with the Registrar of Firms at Hyderabad. It concluded that Secunderabad has the closest and most intimate connection with the arbitration. Reading Section 2(1)(e)(i) with Section 11(12)(b), the Court held that the High Court for the State of Telangana is the competent High Court, and that the Karnataka High Court has no territorial jurisdiction.

Section 11(11) Does Not Settle Jurisdiction

The petitioner filed his petition on 2 June 2025. Respondent Nos. 1 to 3 later filed Arbitration Application No. 259/2025 before the High Court for the State of Telangana on 25 November 2025. According to the petitioner, that application was dismissed by an order dated 14 August 2026 because his application had been made first, and therefore the Karnataka High Court must be the competent court.

The Court did not accept this. It observed that the High Court of Telangana had dismissed the application only because the petitioner had already approached the Karnataka High Court, and that liberty was reserved to the respondents to urge all available grounds before this Court. The Telangana High Court had neither held that the Karnataka High Court has territorial jurisdiction nor that it lacks it. The Court also stated that the mere filing of an earlier application before another High Court does not, by itself, determine the territorial jurisdiction of the subsequent Court.

The Court referred to Hotel Leelaventure Limited v. Appejay Oxford Bookstores Pvt. Ltd., ILR 2006 Karnataka 4449. In the passage extracted, the Court there had observed that where requests are made to different High Courts, the court first approached alone can entertain the request while the earlier petition is pending, and that such a court must first rule on its own jurisdiction before appointing an arbitrator. The petition was dismissed on the ground of lack of territorial jurisdiction.

Practical Takeaways

First, where an arbitration clause names no seat, venue or place, the choice of High Court should be tested against the place with the closest connection to the arbitration before the petition is filed. In this case, the Court treated the firm's registered office, place of business and registration as decisive.

Second, an order under Section 11(11) in favour of the first filer should not be read as a finding on territorial jurisdiction unless the order says so.

Third, where several agreements are invoked together, each arbitration clause may be examined separately, and findings in related proceedings, even prima facie findings, may affect maintainability.

Conclusion

The decision is a reminder that the order of filing and the correctness of the forum are separate questions. A party who files first may still be sent to another High Court if the forum is wrongly chosen.

Comments


bottom of page